Last week went really, super poorly. Pizza, cookies, ice cream and chips were involved. I kept up with exercise and some non-health goals, but basically had a week-long binge. It was really kind of saddening to me that I allowed myself to slip backwards like that. I think it was triggered by the anxiety and self-doubt that comes with a disappointing weigh-in. I should be focused on my health and making long-term, sustainable changes in my lifestyle. If I'm going to get so bent out of shape about a silly number on an ever-fluctuating little machine that only measures one dimension of my progress, then I probably shouldn't be weighing myself so often. I think I'm going to take a break from the scale and maybe check in once a month or so.
When I went to counseling yesterday I talked about binging and asked my counselor his opinion on why it's such a hard habit to break. At first he went on a bit about how "chocolate cake tastes better than tofu and when you're presented with a choice it's hard to get yourself to not want the chocolate cake". He mentioned phrases like "comfort food" and "activating the pleasure center". And I told him that I understood what he was saying but that it didn't quite describe what it felt like for me. Then he started talking about cutting and clients he's seen who self-mutilate in a compulsive effort to experience physical pain that distracts from emotional pain. I felt like everything he was saying about cutting was a pretty accurate match for bingeing too - the shame, secrecy, compulsiveness, lack of self-confidence, need to punish yourself and to distract from deeper emotional issues.
I started thinking that maybe it would help to read a bit about self-mutilation and learn how people successfully overcome that. I have all the knowledge about exercise and nutrition that I could ever need. I make great plans, set reasonable goals, etc. I go through really successful periods, but always slip back into the darkness of bingeing somehow. To me, this is not an issue of willpower or lack of knowledge about weight loss. I think a different perspective could help.
I've been searching a bit online and have actually found a lot of literature linking eating disorders to self-harm behaviors.
One article says that binge eaters have high expectations of themselves and that when they fall short of those standards, they become anxious or depressed and "to escape from this unpleasant state, binge eaters attempt the cognitive response of narrowing attention to the immediate stimulus environment and avoiding broadly meaningful thought."
This article lumps suicide attempts, self-injury and eating disorders together under a label of self-destructive behavior and looks at the connection between these behaviors and "childhood trauma or disrupted parental care". It says that people can react to current stresses "as a return of childhood trauma, neglect and abandonment."
I had very loving parents and was not a victim of any sort of childhood trauma, but I know my issues with shame, binging and sneaking food started when I was young and worsened around puberty when I developed earlier and more excessively than any of my peers and received a lot of unwelcome attention for that before I was emotionally mature enough to deal with it. So - it's interesting to think about those sorts of connections although I'm more interested in developing new coping mechanisms than rehashing the past.
Just food for thought. What do you think? Do you see binging as a diet/self-control issue or as an emotional or psychological issue connected to other self-destructive behaviors? Have you overcome binging or self-mutilating?
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)







4 comments:
I don't think bingeing is a self-control issue. I think it's more emotional and psychological, but I don't have any words of wisdom to help you conquer it. My daughter did some minor self-mutilating. It wasn't to the point of cutting, mostly just scratching herself. She was not happy that we'd moved the year she turned 15. She had a few years of counseling and was on antidepressants for a while. Wish I could help more. I will pray that you find the help you need.
Sounds like we have a lot in common. I was raised well, for the most part, with good parents but not always great. I developed really earlier and too much and too quickly, it had a bad effect on me.
I binge sometimes. And whenever I think I've finally overcome it, it will happen again. For me I think it only occurs after I've been restricting. I just want everything I didn't allow myself to have!
I also did self mutilation many years ago when I was in high school. As a bratty teenager though, I think I was just in need of attention. I don't remember having a hard time getting over it.
I feel that for behaviors like this, everyone has to learn how to overcome it their own way. There's no magic solution. I'd really love to quit binging for good so I hope some day I figure it out!
Hi Rachel,
I definitely agree that there is a connection between binging and emotional issues. I've never thought of it as a self mutilating behavior but it does make sense. My counselor suggested for me that it was one way of meeting my own needs/wants since it seemed like in so many other areas of my life I was not getting those things. For me, I think the food is not about self mutilating, but it's about giving myself a hug, so to speak, for all the beating-up I do to myself otherwise or for all the ways in which I think I've fallen short.
The thing I'm curious about is why do you not want to rehash the past? (This is a hypothetical question for you to think about -- I certainly do not mean for you to bring up emotional issues in a forum like this.) If binging is one way of "avoiding meaningful thought", then wouldn't "staying away from rehashing" also be avoiding? Do you think looking at some of the feelings you are avoiding through binging would help you deal with them instead of turning to food?
As I indirectly mentioned above, I have a counselor too, so I know firsthand that examining the feelings behind one's behavior is not always easy, nor is it an enjoyable thing - most of the time.
I do hope you work through this. Best of luck.
Post a Comment